I used to putt with Magnets, Challengers and the Banger GT. Love them all. Heck ... give me ANY disc and I'm probably going to love it ... nobody is paying me to play with anything, so what the heck!
What's most important. Practice ... period. Doesn't matter what you throw. I can throw any putter just as good as the next. I even love to use my Rocs for putting sometimes, and have been known to leave my putters in the car and putt with a groovy 175g JK/KC Roc I have. If you're wondering what that is, it's a KC Roc made with JK plastic ... nice and soft and groovy, LOL.
I loves me some Blowfly! For me it has a nice "dead fish" flop if I miss and very dependable flight. Plus I can use it as a hand puppet. The first time you fold it in half and then fold it again and then throw it at the chains like a baseball, the look on peoples faces who are unfamiliar with the disc is priceless. Even better if it happens to be the one out of 100 times that it actually stays in the basket from that type of throw. But if you throw it as designed, it will do its best to crawl in the basket for you. Within 30 feet, this is my go to putter.
challengers for putts inside 30ft, outside 30ft and outside 150-180ft. challengers are the best. Put both mine in a pond last night and i wasnt about to go out like that so i had to go swimming after them. The fucking water was freezing but thats why u dont play drunk golf :)
I started out with my infamous Rhino, love the disc, and when pressure is high I always grab it. Hits every time! Otherwise, I am a big fan of the Banger GT, one red, 167 one white 175. These discs will do anything you want them to, with immense control.
Pro D Challengers, I use them for all putts inside of 60ft. Then I go to my old X APX for anything outside of the challenger's range but still in putting range. The challengers are very predictable and are a nice stable putter that beats in nicely over time. My X APX just floats straight as an arrow with little effort for those longer putts. Both are great discs that have been permanently in my bag for over a year and have treated me well.