Try looking up a local trophy and engraving shop. We have a local guy Ryans Trophies in MT, 2 sided full color really sweet. They are a strong plastic with a clear rubber lanyard. They ended up costing around $5 last year. Here are a couple pics, as well our new design for 08 season!
Just got our 09 tags from JJ at Wholesale Metals as well. Getting alot of good comments from other clubs around the metroplex too. I did the basic design and he did the set-up, easy to work with, couteous and very fast from start to finish, we had our tags in less than a week.
Check with Charles at firstname.lastname@example.org He does Amazing work and even goes the extra mile to make sure you are happy with the product. He has an amazing library of clipart to draw from and his turnover is Super Fast!! We called him in a pinch for my son's Birthday party and were amazed with the Awesome service we recieved!! Charles ROC's!! Tell him Marck and Karalyn sent you from Hallsville, MO
http://discgolfdiva.startlogic.com/index.html did our clubs and they are very good quality. The link below shows the options and our clubs is the 2" square steel. I do not think any have broken like the plastic tags we had the last couple of years.
I do bag tags. We have steel, anodized aluminum, leather, neon leather (new) and a quick turn around. We're bagging orders to ship right now. Check it out, email through the website and I'll send you a price list. Thanks! Kathy
you can also look up any trophy shop, they will generally have the laser engraving and color dye-sub options for dog tags, luggage tags etc. It's good to support the disc scene as well your local mom-&-pops!