Do I return this disc?

I recently risked my health to go swimming in a seriously infested pond to find a disc that I threw in the day before and possibly a few others. I ended up finding 16 other discs in the process. I found a good buddy's disc and another that didn't belong to a buddy but I know the guy and I couldn't keep the disc and feel good about myself. My question is- should I return a disc to someone when I am the person that did the dirty work to retrieve the disc. I always return discs that I find on dry land, but I kind of feel like if that person wanted that disc back they would have done the same thing that I did. Is this gonna screw up my Karma!?

[Wicked Dyes]

Return it... its good karma

[Disc-O Golf]

I agree.

[camera guy]

be cool, return it to it's owner

[Disc-O Golf]

Yes!

[Jamie 'gr8rocshot' Ruane]

Yeah...I agree...return it.

[Disc-O Golf]

Best choice. Return it.

[Bryan Carr]

do unto others...I've gotten in my fair share of muck holes to grab a disc I lost only to return with someone elses. even if the person didn't want to go to the trouble to get it that piece of plastic obviously meant something to them. I return everything I find with a name and number. just a name, I'll do my best, but even if I can't return them I don't throw them. you never know when you'll come across a golfer that has their name on a disc you nabbed from a scum infested pond.

[Charles Isaac]

You know . . . this may be 'bad' but you did the dirty work. Return the disc for a small fee say $3. I would gladly pay $3 or $4 to get some of my discs back. If I could get my red storm back for $4 I would be so happy.

The local store will buy them and sell back to you at what he paid for them, good guy.


However, if you found a disc under a tree, just call.

[Don Cook]

maybe im the only one that gets joy out of seeing the persons reaction to the returned disc that they had written of to the water gods.but just the smile and thanks they give is payment enough .i couldnt charge but have payed kids for going in to get discs but they never asked for the payment

[The FORCE]

deep down we all know what the right thing to do is...

[Rescue]

I'd return it, besides. You don't know if he tried to find it. He just might have and wasn't as lucky as you. No name or number on the disc..Merry Christmas, it's yours! but if there is. You gotta try and return it.

[Disc nut]

I have left a few discs in the water and I'm not willing to go after them. I do not expect to get them back. If you leave it its gone, not yours anymore,its been abandoned, finders keepers. If you know the person thats different, give it back.