Is this disc OB??

The pond is OB... where exactly does it start?

[Birdie-man]

Maybe this angle will help. The guy that chucked it here never takes relief for some strange reason.

[The FORCE]

Thats the silliest thing I've ever heard. Amateurs are funny. The disc is definitely in bounds.

[Carlie Thomas]

I would say you would have to play it

[Jim Coonradt]

Still completely surrounded by water.

[Donny Olow]

That Mud looks really deep !!!

[Donny Olow]

I'd make him play the shot where it is !!!

[Jim Coonradt]

Isn't the rule still "completely surrounded by water"?

[Birdie-man]

The disc is in the mud, not in the water. Casual relief marks the spot on more stable dirt and less mud. The angle of the picture isn't the greatest...

[Jim Coonradt]

The mud is completely surrounded by water so therefore the disc is completely surrounded by water. If the disc lands completely dry on an island in a stream that is OB then the disc would still be OB. I think...

Now if you can find a strip of mud that completely attaches back to shore it then gets a little more confusing because is the mud composed of dirt or water? I know that we are spliiting hairs here. Get out the microscope.

[Paul Novak]

If you are beating me it is definitely out of bounds, if I am beating you I think it could be in bounds. LOL

[Birdie-man]

That was my thinking also : )

[Ben Calhoun]

Also, benefit of the doubt on the ob line is supposed to go to the player so it'd likely be called in-bounds as it is not clear at all, clearly.