Strong head wind disc, will do the same thing everytime, I just picked up my second one after aceing with my first. Xcal is a disc you want in your bag. Once broken in it should stand up for a bit and still come back.
About the Star XCaliber-
The XCaliber is for those who have got to have the biggest and the baddest. Extremely fast with glide and stability. The XCaliber achieves maximum distance when thrown low, flat, and hard. This is the one for confident bombs in windy conditions. The XCaliber has the stability to let the biggest arms throw with full power. If you have a cannon for an arm, you'll want an XCaliber. Great disc for sidearm throwers and those with lots of power. It can handle headwinds and throws with off axis torque. This disc has a larger learning curve for beginning players as it requires heavy torque, snap and spin to perform.
I've had a yellow max weight one since about the middle of '09 and it has done me well for overhands, sidearm, and windy days. It is nice and seasoned now and works really well still. If you're looking for one disc to perform like I mentioned this would be a great option for you.