The Community of Disc Golfers and About All Things Disc Golf
Historically, hi-lo or pro-am best shot has proven itself better at club building. Eventually your random draw players will figure out it is a sucker game except for the elite players. Only an elite player can be on a team with two elite players, and week after week, the winning teams are the ones with two elite players. Elite players might be am 2s at your league. that's why i show up when i can! You build a club of hustlers and suckers when you build it on a game that appeals to hustlers and suckers. That's not the best foundation for a club.
You don't see me taking my wife and kids to random draw, except now that Kelsey is as good as most amateur men, she and i play some random draw when we can. I take them to pro-am or hi-lo where they can play on the am or lo side, draw a good partner and have fun. Nothing will drive the women and am 4s away faster than when they show up a couple weeks in a row and get another woman or am 4 for a partner.
When I look around and see clubs that are friendly to women and lo-ams, I usually also see clubs that have lots of members and volunteers. Discontinuum had about 130 members last year and they run a weekly pro-am league with bubble rules. Kensington was big when it was pro-am lizard and disappeared when it went to random draw.
I'd like to start a Sunday afternoon hi-lo league. Maybe do hi-lo based on PDGA ratings and a ladder system with Mulligan chits paid out to players who finish out of the cash. I'm still talking Diana and the girls into the idea. They are fine with Sunday afternoon casual family golf. And we are losing Kelsey to summer camp and college soon. This idea might percolate until my disc golf side kick abandons me for the pursuits of young adulthood.